does not like the people’s request. He sees in it a rejection of himself and everything he has striven for. Still, he dutifully takes it to YHWH. YHWH’s response to the people’s request is self-contradictory. YHWH first states that the people have rejected him but not Samuel (8:7), and then instantly retracts this by saying to Samuel, “Just as they have done to me … they are now doing to you” (v. 8). This symptom of confusion has not been sufficiently attended to by commentators. It is a signal that
Page 62